The Power of Radically Candid Conversations for Performance Development

As a leader, one of the most important responsibilities you have is to help your team members grow and develop. Performance development conversations are a critical part of this process, but they can be challenging to get right. In this post, we'll explore why radically candid conversations are essential for effective performance development and how you can use them to create a culture that retains top talent.

The Importance of Feedback: A Personal Experience

Early in my career, I had a manager named Bob who was a master at providing feedback. He was always direct and honest, but he did it in a way that showed he cared about my growth and success. One day, after I had given a presentation that I thought went well, Bob pulled me aside and said, "That was a good start, but here are a few things you can do to make it even better next time." He then proceeded to give me specific, actionable feedback that I could use to improve.

At the time, I was taken aback by Bob's directness. But as I reflected on the conversation, I realized that his feedback was a gift. He had taken the time to observe my performance, think about how I could improve, and share his insights with me. That conversation was a turning point in my career, and it taught me the importance of providing feedback for performance development.

Performance Management vs. Performance Development

It's important to distinguish between performance management and performance development. Performance management is about setting goals, measuring progress, and holding people accountable for results. Performance development, on the other hand, is about helping people grow and improve over time.

While both are important, many organizations focus too heavily on performance management at the expense of performance development. They may have annual performance reviews and goal-setting processes in place, but they don't invest enough time and energy in ongoing feedback and coaching.

The Role of Radical Candor in Performance Development

This is where Radical Candor comes in. Radical Candor is a framework developed by Kim Scott that emphasizes the importance of caring personally and challenging directly. When applied to performance development conversations, Radical Candor means being honest and direct with your feedback while also showing that you care about the person's growth and success.

Radically candid conversations can be uncomfortable at first, but they are essential for effective performance development. By providing specific, actionable feedback in a caring way, you help your team members understand where they need to improve and how they can do so. You also build trust and show that you are invested in their development.

The HIP Approach to Radically Candid Performance Development

To put Radical Candor into practice, Kim Scott recommends using the HIP approach:

  1. Humble - Approach the conversation with humility and a genuine desire to help the other person grow.

  2. Helpful - Provide specific, actionable feedback that the person can use to improve their performance.

  3. Immediate - Don't wait for a formal review process to provide feedback. Give it in the moment, when it's most relevant and actionable.

  4. In Person - Whenever possible, have these conversations face-to-face or over video chat. This allows for better communication and connection.

By using the HIP approach, you can have radically candid conversations that drive real performance development.

Aligning Performance Development with Performance Management

Finally, it's important to align performance development with performance management. While the two are distinct, they should work together to create a culture that retains top talent.

One way to do this is to use performance development conversations to inform performance management processes. For example, if you've been providing regular feedback and coaching to a team member throughout the year, you should have a clear understanding of their strengths and areas for improvement when it comes time for their annual review.

Another way to align the two is to make performance development a key part of your performance management process. Instead of just focusing on goals and metrics, make sure you're also setting development goals and providing the support and resources needed to achieve them.


Radically candid conversations are essential for effective performance development. By providing specific, actionable feedback in a caring way, you can help your team members grow and improve over time. And by aligning performance development with performance management, you can create a culture that retains top talent and drives long-term success.

Empower your whole team tothrive.
Join us on our mission to build happier, more cohesive teams